My first baby was not going to use a pacifier.
How awful they looked, like garish plastic plugs. They were tooth-terrorizing drool dams. I likened them to baby’s first bubble gum, smacked and sucked and chomped on rudely. Pacifiers were a crutch for lazy, uncaring parents who couldn’t or wouldn’t take the time to delve into the reasons behind crying.
I had visions of how it would be between the two of us. I’d be the mother in the white cotton lace trimmed gown rocking the Gerber baby near a window looking out onto a misty meadow whilst violins soared. A gaudy plastic pacifier was never jammed between those rosebud lips.
One night, when she was about three weeks old, I stood in her bedroom swaying her bundled body and crying right along with her. She was fed, dry, and swaddled. My husband and I looked at each other and the fraying ends of our ropes. One of us suggested getting a pacifier.
They were buried on the bottom shelf of the changing table, still in their packages—unwelcome gifts from a baby shower. While I rocked, he boiled water to sterilize the pacifiers. After five minutes rollicking in the boil, they were ready. We ran them under cold water. I placed one to her lips. The business end disappeared and so did her cries.
Something amazing didn’t happen. My newborn daughter didn’t warp into a junior version of Rosanne abusing a stick of gum in her wisecracking mouth. A mullet didn’t sprout from her downy scalp. She was peaceful, and at that moment there was nothing more beautiful than feeling we had helped our daughter and ourselves by making a good parenting decision—to let go of a preconceived notion of how it should be done.
So began our daughter’s long, passionate regard for the pacifier. In my dad’s side of the family, pacifiers were called “schnoolies” so we did the same. Then one day, at the mall, an elderly man approached Aidan in her stroller and declared, “Look at that little guy and his stooley!” He chuckled and walked off. We thought it was funny because Aidan was clearly not a little guy and the word he used was so close to our word for pacifier. We began to call it “stooley” too.
As she grew, she renamed it “choo choo” which we adopted. Choo Choo got her through the transitional weeks after her baby brother Ryley (who never used a Choo Choo because he didn’t need it) was born. On her second birthday Choo Choo went Bye Bye Cold Cold Turkey Turkey. We had been warning her for months the day was coming when Choo Choo would have to go, so she accepted it very well.
Sammy was a triple fisted Choo Choo man, often having one in his mouth and one in each hand. He’d switch them around according to a mysterious formula he devised, probably based on taste, temperature, and texture. Tommy took tender care of his charges, rarely losing them under the car seat or rudely throwing them across the mall parking lot. He further refined the name to “Coo Coo” where it stands today. Joel also used Coo Coos, but not as long as the other boys or Aidan.
I said I’d never co-sleep. We did. I never imagined nursing past a year. I did. I wasn’t going to let my kids drink pop, eat a McNugget, or watch “The Simpsons”. I have. Did I cave? Was I weak? Joel screams “BlickDonald’s!!” when he spies the golden arches during our travels around town.
Some may see that as a horrifying sign of bad mothering. I think of it as sight-reading.
Whether or not the new baby is introduced to our pal Coo Coo is entirely up to the baby. His or her disposition will be the deciding factor. It’s the first act of trust I demonstrate to our little ones. It has to start somewhere, at some time. Of course my husband and I are the ultimate authorities and will give and take the Coo Coo as we deem fit—but I’d never dream of taking it away just because of some sort of twisted mother-pride that demands I cling to a certain set of dos and don’ts outlined in a book, on a website, or in a gauzy dream formed by the mind of sheer inexperience. The lace on that nightgown itches, anyway.
~~~The picture is from itsmybinky.com, where you can purchase this $17,000 white gold and diamond encrusted pacifier.